Group at Bonaly Tower

Group at Bonaly Tower

David Octavius Hill
British, 1802–1870
Robert Adamson
British, 1821–1848
1840
A 1840 carbon print photograph of a carefully staged group at Bonaly Tower in which Hill sought to translate the compositional and narrative qualities of painting into the new medium of photography.
What strikes you is the tableau-like stillness—people posed like figures in a domestic painting, rendered in soft sepia tones and gentle focus against the stone steps and doorway.
An early example of photographic portraiture that helped demonstrate photography’s capacity to rival painting for composition and storytelling while promoting more permanent processes like the carbon print for documentary and artistic use.
Medium
Carbon print
Dimensions
6 × 8" (15.3 × 20.4 cm)
Classification
Department
Credit
Gift of Warner Communications, Inc.
Accession
1151.1979
Palette
Art Terms
Exhibitions
View on moma.org

Semantic Neighborhood

Near field – 8 neighboring works

press T

Keyboard Shortcuts

S Cycle source (semantic/color/artist/...)
P Toggle Sources column
V Cycle center mode (viewer/browser/split)
I Toggle Inspector column
\ Swap split direction
T Toggle toolbar
C Toggle palette strips
Shift+C Sort by color similarity
Shift+H Immersive mode (viewer only)
1-5 Set thumbnail size
? Toggle this help

Column shortcuts require ultrawide (2xl+) viewport

Very Similar

> 65%
Sobieski Stuart 76%

Sobieski Stuart

David Octavius Hill

1840

Sobieski Stuart 76% David Octavius Hill 1840 Carbon print Photograph Photography 7 3/4 × 5 5/16 (19.7 × 13.5... British 1152.1979
John Murray 75%

John Murray

David Octavius Hill

1840

John Murray 75% David Octavius Hill 1840 Carbon print Photograph Photography 7 3/8 × 5 3/8" (19.7 × 13.5... British 1153.1979
D.O. Hill and Companion in Greyfriar's Churchyard, Edinburgh 74%

D.O. Hill and Companion in Greyfriar's Churchyard, Edinburgh

David Octavius Hill

1840

D.O. Hill and Companion in Greyfriar's Churchyard, Edinburgh 74% David Octavius Hill 1840 Carbon print Photograph Photography 15 3/4 × 12 1/2" (39.2 × 31... British 1154.1979
Debating Society Meeting at Merchiston Castle 73%

Debating Society Meeting at Merchiston Castle

David Octavius Hill

1840

Debating Society Meeting at Merchiston Castle 73% David Octavius Hill 1840 Carbon print Photograph Photography 9 × 11 1/2" (22.9 × 29.1 cm) British 1149.1979
Col. Burns, Son of the Poet 72%

Col. Burns, Son of the Poet

David Octavius Hill

1843-48

Col. Burns, Son of the Poet 72% David Octavius Hill 1843-48 Carbon print, printed c. 1920 Photograph Photography 8 × 5 7/8" (20.3 × 14.9 cm) British 673.1976
David Octavius Hill 71%

David Octavius Hill

David Octavius Hill

1840

David Octavius Hill 71% David Octavius Hill 1840 Photogravure Photograph Photography 7 15/16 × 5 13/16" (19.8 × ... British 1143.1979
D.O. Hill and others in Greyfriars Churchyard 71%

D.O. Hill and others in Greyfriars Churchyard

David Octavius Hill

c. 1841-48

D.O. Hill and others in Greyfriars Churchyard 71% David Octavius Hill c. 1841-48 Calotype Photograph Photography 8 5/8 × 6 3/8" (22.0 × 17.0... British 841.1978
Mons Meg, Edinburgh Castle 71%

Mons Meg, Edinburgh Castle

David Octavius Hill

1843-48

Mons Meg, Edinburgh Castle 71% David Octavius Hill 1843-48 Carbon print Photograph Photography 12 1/8 × 15 1/2" (30.8 × 39... British 672.1976